By Jim Sack

K-2, another tax abatement, comedic backfilling over the new mayor’s office, a request to vacate a street where high on council’s agenda, all interesting, but mere backdrop for the looming battle between council and the mayor over their balance of power.

Just six council members showed up last night. Councilman Shoaff did not answer the roll call, Councilman Hines was absent, Councilwoman Brown’s chair was vacant. So, President Bender gaveled down promptly at 5:30pm to the cues of the access channel camera crew.

Lincoln Printing wants an abatement to purchase new equipment and create two new jobs. Passed. A construction company wants an abatement to increase their capacity. Passed. Dr. Arthur Snyder, the very successful president of rapidly growing Indiana Tech, was on hand to speak on behalf of a street vacation within his campus. Staff tossed a temporary spanner in the works, however, by recommending the request be tabled until the school and fire department can work out a few details. It was so tabled.

Then, the folderol swirling about the new mayoral offices resumed, and finally a group of students came to plead with council to rid the city of K-2.

After the theater and the mundane had concluded, Mitch Harper, councilman from the west side, quietly introduced a series of ordinances, on behalf of the absent Liz Brown, to be debated and acted upon a subsequent meetings. The ordinances dealt with governmental ethics, transparency and citizen involvement on the micro level. He quietly read them in one by one to no noticeable reaction from his colleagues, but there was already plenty of dust in the air. A battle of executive versus the legislative had been joined weeks before and rejoined that very morning. Contracts, specifically discretionary contracts between the mayor and consultants and for less than $100,000, was the battlefield.

Earlier yesterday the mayor had declared that a task force would be established to determine how contracts would be handled in the future. He named his deputy mayor, Beth Malloy, Council President Marty Bender, City Clerk Sandy Kennedy to sit on the task force, and invited the council president to name two council members to fill out the task force. Mayor Henry recommended to President Bender that two critics of his conduct in matters contractual be appointed from council, Ms. Brown and Glynn Hines.

It was an effort to get out ahead of growing community frustration and mistrust of the mayor’s way of hiring consultants who work on various matters, such as bringing a casino to town or more recently, the effort to retain Navistar jobs in Fort Wayne. Contracts amounting to less than $100,000 need not be submitted to council for approval. It is perceived that contracts for more questionable projects are brought in under the radar, the $100k radar, to keep them from the eyes of council. It is also perceived that, as in the case with the casino, that what the administration says and what the administration does are two different things.

So, increasingly suspicious council members have been getting quite an earful from enough constituents to feel empowered to cut that $100k threshold to a much lower level, as has been proposed by Ms. Brown. The mayor, now on the defensive, made a move yesterday to break out of council’s encirclement, to wrest control from council and to maintain his powers.

It is a classic governmental confrontation: The mayor wants to keep some of his transactions private for a variety of reasons, including fear that complete transparency will undermine negotiations, may complicate deals and may end up costing us, we taxpayers, much more to pay for major steps forward. Council, conversely, sniffs misuse of power and is determined to curtail some of the executive’s prerogatives.

So, yesterday morning, with impending council action on the evening’s agenda, the mayor struck first by naming the panel to steal council’s thunder and regain control of the process. The blue ribbon panel, stacked in the mayor’s favor, would essentially deep six the process and protect the mayor’s power. Word is the committee may never meet. Council action will proceed. Odds are the arbitrary threshold will be reduced. The mayor will argue for a free hand and try to write guidelines to that end.

In other matters last night, the upset over the elegant offices into which the mayor will soon move, was humorously resolved. Those sumptuous offices were left behind by Lincoln National when they abandoned Fort Wayne for Philadelphia. Last week councilman Tom Smith voiced some concern over the ostentatious new mayor’s office and wondered if the decor might be toned down a bit to avoid citizen outrage. Tim Pape, councilman from the south side, spoke about the beauty of the offices and that we, here in Fort Wayne, should eschew our miserly attitudes and embrace the opulance to wow visitors. Karen Goldner, council woman from the north central, asked then if Mr. Smith, a fiscal hawk, was willing to spend tax dollars to tear out the grand offices. He demurred. So, in act two last night, Mr. Smith drew laughter when he compared the opulent offices to the recently acclaimed toilet facilities at the Embassy voted by some magazine among the loveliest potties in the country and embraced Mr. Pape’s view of things. Mr. Pape waxed on about the glories of Fort Wayne ad tedium to end the comedy.

K-2 was the point of an appearance by a half dozen young people and their adult leaders in public time last night. K-2 is a dangerous and legal drug. The kids made clear how dangerous it is. They also called on council to act. Council passed on acting, noting instead that it is a legislative matter. A simple resolution would have done to voice concern.

In conclusion, there were numerous comments on the life of Ben GiaQuinta, state representative, real estate agent, township trustee board member, who recently died. I only knew him in passing, but each passing was marked by his kindness and willingness to give me his full attention. His wife died last year and she was a remarkably kind and reserved woman. His kids have done quite well. We could use a few more Ben GiaQuintas in this world.

One more thing. Joe Fox is the mayor’s new PR director and he worked council members hard last night on behalf of his boss. Mr. Fox is a political journeyman who’s past work includes managing Mayor Henry’s last campaign on his lengthy resume. Now, instead of living out of a suitcase, he is a resident of West Central. There are those who believe Mr. Fox, and his immediate boss, Beth Malloy, the deputy mayor, are just what Mayor Henry has needed to provide better leadership for the community. Mr. Fox is tough and savvy and doesn’t shirk to give full throat to the policies of the administration. Heretofore, only Tim Pape has been such an eloquent advocate for the mayor. I would guess Mr. Pape appreciates the reinforcements. As for Ms. Malloy, she has won a lot of respect for her candor and professionalism in the short period she has been here.

If you find this article informative? Consider donating any amount you choose.

No related posts.

15 Responses to “Battle Lines are Drawn at Council”
  1. Mark Andrews says:

    Jim as usual you are simply amazing!!! I learnt more in the last 5 minutes than a week of reading the news!!!!

  2. DouglasB says:

    This blue ribbon panel ,,, will it only review consultant contracts, or other contracts? Who is the chair? Under what Indiana statute will it operate? What and when will it report to Council or citizens? And, how will it be held accountable to me, the poor bastard that has to pay for all of this?
    And in the end, does this mean we will continue to see a multitude of 99,999 dollar contracts that are issued with absolutely no review by anyone else, other than the administration?

  3. Jim Sack says:

    Thanks. That is very kind.

  4. Jim Sack says:

    Well, Douglas B, the members are to be, if it gets off the ground, the deputy mayor, Beth Malloy, the Prez of Council, Marty Bender, City Clerk Sandy Kennedy and two council members to be appointed by Mr. Bender. Mr Henry suggested they be Liz Brown and Glynn Hines. I do not know which statute would empower them, but the mayor call establish committees and task forces, as he did with the co-location task force. Council members expressed hope that the task force would be open to all to watch and listen. I wonder why there needs to be a committee at all, given council has introduced ordinances dealing with the consultants. It would have been appropriate for the council president to disregard the call to form a committee and let the legislation take its course. As for accountable to you, well your rep, I believe is Mitch, a critic of the process, and nearby lives John Shoaff who is also wary of the contracts and their lack of consultation with council on these matters. Each would welcome your comments, truly. As to the outcome, hmmmm. It may not get off the ground.

  5. Jim Sack says:

    Mark, if I may add, I have a healthy respect for Bob Caylor at the News Sentinel and Ben Lanka at the Journal. They work under deadline and they have space requirements. AWB allows me time to report and enough space to tell the story I believe unfolded. Each reporter tells a different story. There were a dozen potential subjects last night, I chose the one I thought salient. I could also have written about the way Dr. Snyder was treated. He could have been informed of the process and told that staff would not recommend passage, but rather request a delay. I don't think he was happy. But, that is for another story another day. I read Lanka and Bob whenever I can and I eagerly await Kevin Leininger's work. I hope you continue reading the papers. They are quite a community asset that I support.

  6. DouglasB says:

    Jim, thanks for the info. By the way, while I am fortunate to have Mr. Shoaff as a close neighbor, I am sad to report that Mitch Harper is not my councilman. Instead I'm in the 5th district and suffer with the representation of Mr. Pape. I have been presently surprised by the assistance of Mr. Harper on more than one occasion. His efforts to help all citizens is much like that of Don Schmidt. For years I was in the 1st district, and was ignored by my councilman. But, I call to Mr. Schmidt always got results, even though he represented the 2nd district. Sure miss him on council.

  7. Mike H says:

    I also had Mitch Harper help on an issue that was not in his district.

  8. Jim Sack says:

    Mitch is a very good council man. He is polite, quite knowledgeable about matters legislative, the county's unofficial historian and seems to see some value in everyone and almost everything locally. The longer I know him the more I am impressed with the service he gives to us all.

    Also, I read last night's News Sentinel and noticed that Bob Caylor had three pieces in about the council meeting. Great. Simply wonderful. He covered the K2 issue, he covered the side story of the sumptuous new mayor's office and then the meeting in general. I enjoyed each piece and felt he got the essence of each topic. I subscribe because the papers make us a community, not just a collection of sub-communities.

  9. Jim Sack says:

    Mitch is a very good council man. He is polite, quite knowledgeable about matters legislative, the county's unofficial historian and seems to see some value in everyone and almost everything locally. The longer I know him the more I am impressed with the service he gives to us all.

  10. Bob G. says:

    Jim:
    I always look forward to YOUR "review" of the City Council meetings…better than watching it live, I can tell you.
    You don't spin it at all.

    You provide the nuts and bolts of the meeting, and I enjoy that.
    Keep those hits coming!

  11. Jim Sack says:

    Thank you, Bob. It is enjoyable to watch them at work. Having a vote at the table is a big deal. I worked to win votes on an issue a couple years back and I learned quickly that they had a vote and I did not. I could make eloquent points, argue the utility, the cost, etc., but in the end only nine people were empowered to vote. So, it is interesting to watch them at work and to hear their comments before, after and between meetings. I hope it is helpful.

  12. Mark Andrews says:

    No worries there! I have met Dr. Snyder under totally different circumstances and he is really enjoyable to talk to. Indiana Tech has came a long way since the incident in1982 which could have set the stage for what people thought about the school. I really enjoy pointing out what a difference Tech has made to that immediate neighborhood and should be held as an example of urban growth.

  13. Steve G says:

    well deserved praise for Mitch….he certainly has established the standard for an elected official….

  14. Evert Mol says:

    Jim-

    Another great commentary. Although I was crushed by your refusal to root for the Orange, you make up for it with your council coverage.

  15. Jim Sack says:

    Hey, I cheered for die Oranje. Didn't do much good. Now, Robben and van Bommel go back to Munich, along with most of the German team and the best Argentinian defender. They should have a great season. Does, by the way, Ajax still have a team?

  16.  
Trackbacks
  1.  
Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


© 2006 - 2012 Angry White Boy
Feel free to steal any of our stuff, just be sure to give us credit, and a link back
Share


eXTReMe Tracker



http://www.wikio.com

Listed on BlogShares