All-American City or All American waste of money?
Posted by AWB in City & County Government
The city has been touting the fact that Fort Wayne is one of the 30 finalist for the All-American City Award. 10 winners will be selected. The city has been attempting to raise money to send some 25 or so individuals at a cost of about $1000 per person on an all-expense paid vacation to the newly renovated Tampa Marriott Waterside Hotel and Marina where they will participate in the American Idol of Cities grand ceremonies.
The goal is to raise $25,000 for travel, hotel and other expenses. The city has already raised more than $6,000, said Rebecca Karcher, spokeswoman for Henry. Local businesses and people are also encouraged to donate to the travel fund.
CRITERIA
For a community to be named an All-America City, it must be able to demonstrate successful resolution of community issues through collaborative effort. Award winning criteria include the following: active citizen involvement, effective and efficient government performance, maximized local philanthropic and volunteer resources, a strong capacity for cooperation and consensus building, community vision and pride, inter-group relations, community information sharing, and intercommunity cooperation.All-America City Award Criteria
Participation of the public, private and nonprofit sectors and key constituencies to the maximum extent possible; Recognition and involvement of diverse segments and perspectives (ethnic, racial, socio-economic, age, etc.) in community decision-making; Creative use and leveraging of community resources; Significant and specific community achievements; Projects that address the community’s most important needs; Cooperation across jurisdictional boundaries;
Cooperation across jurisdictional boundaries? The city of Fort Wayne and the County of Allen = cooperation?
Fighting over bridge repairs
Fighting over the wheel tax, (which city council approved today).
Fighting over the 911 call center
<insert your example here>
Or take the Wayne Township office and the infighting there not to mention the investigation by the Local Government Efficiency Study Committee.
Clear demonstration of project results and impacts (dollars raised or lives impacted); Projects which have impacted the community significantly within the last three years, and have potential to continue improving the quality of life; and at least one project should document ways in which the lives of children and youth have been tangibly improved.
I guess that means they can’t talk about The Harrison, or Renaissance Pointe or the Public Safety Academy, to name a few.
Deputy Mayor Greg Purcell will be part of the group, as will Larry Wardlaw, vice president of Asher Agency Inc., a marketing firm in Fort Wayne.
Oh that’s nice, send someone from the Asher Agency. If you recall, Asher sold or gave a list that had been given to Asher for the purpose of a certain republican candidate’s political campaign to Fort Wayne Community School’s Yellow Ribbon petition group. That violated confidentiality standards that clients expect to receive when dealing with sensitive personal data.
On top of that, Asher was paid $15,000 for a new logo for Fort Wayne Community Schools, (paid for by you) that was nothing more than a knockoff of their own logo. A 10 year-old could have done that, (image courtesy of Fetchy). Maybe Wardlaw/Asher could donate the $15k towards the trip?

Although the city has been preparing for the competition since August 2008, Wardlaw said he was only recently called in to help “jazz up the show.” For the next few weeks, he will coach delegation members and act as emcee for the group’s presentation, he said.
At what price? Asher’s the most inept expensive agency in town.
The All American City Award is old and tired. Nearly every large and mid-sized city has won the award at least once, and personally, I just don’t see the value. Take the $25K and feed some people.
You may disagree, and if you do then I suppose the question to ask is, does Fort Wayne deserve it? Click here to see what people in Salisbury, Maryland have to say about their attempt.
If you find this article informative? Consider donating any amount you choose.
No related posts.
Tags: All-American City Award, Asher Agency, Larry Wardlaw

Entries (RSS)

At one time I wanted to start a new blog and call it “Celebrate Fort Wayne” and go around to all the local businesses (or organization, people, or what-have-you) who are busting their asses at the core, on their own, perhaps against the wind, and truly celebrate what they are doing with a little bloggie publicity. With my direct contacts it would have started with Spiece, Turnstone, etc…. and then it could have went from there but I don’t think I have the energy or time to do that right now. I’d rather hear about that than the fakie stuff.
Dan- See my comment to the aroundfortwayne blog on May 13 -the post title was”Easy Ways to help the All-America Cuity Effort”. Also, see how Toledo responded to their city being nominated at http://www.thurbersthoughts.blogspot.com/2009/04/controversy-over-all-american-city-award.html
Perhaps one of “the criteria” should be noting the fact that:
“ANY city is ONLY AS GOOD as it’s WORST AREA”.
Then, they can run with THAT from there…
The link to Thurbers Thoughts I listed, doesn’t work. Just go to http://www.thurbersthoughts.blogspot.com and go to her posts on April 4 titled “Controversy over A.A.City Award” and April 29 titled”Others question value of A.A. City Awards”
I heard it said recently (and liked it so much that I’d share) that the FWCS logo is just the Asher logo with dunce caps on.
As far as the All America City–let those going pay the grand apiece on their own. There’s no one on the committee, I’m sure, that can’t afford to take the vacation on their dime….and it’s an honor just to be asked (rolls eyes.)
I was once told that anything you nominate yourself for, probably isn’t worth much if you win.
For those that don’t know Steve Michaels’ comment about the Asher Agency concerns the fact that Asher designed the FWCS’ new logo for $15,000 . The logo looks just like the Asher logo. Asher also headed the FWCS’ $500 million bond issue drive. at a total cost of about $600,000. They lost by 14,000 votes. Now the City hires Asher to head the All American City contest. Ft Wayne and the FWCS are the only fools that rewards failure.
i saw last night that the wiz… er, the tin caps are having an event sunday(?) to raise money for this. i wonder if the rich elite of ft wayne will ever consider raising money for something the poor slob gives a s@#t about. gee, the three rivers festival could use some funding…